Comments on: who’s watches the watchmen?(no spoiler content) http://www.broadaudit.com/archives/62#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=whos-watches-the-watchmenno-spoiler-content Audit: (noun) any thorough assessment or review Thu, 13 Oct 2011 20:49:17 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.1 hourly 1 By: craig G http://www.broadaudit.com/archives/62/comment-page-1#comment-129 craig G Thu, 12 Mar 2009 01:38:56 +0000 http://www.broadaudit.com/?p=62#comment-129 I am the only person out of my friends in whistler that thought this movie sucked......thank you I am the only person out of my friends in whistler that thought this movie sucked……thank you

]]> By: Jered http://www.broadaudit.com/archives/62/comment-page-1#comment-127 Jered Sat, 07 Mar 2009 12:48:51 +0000 http://www.broadaudit.com/?p=62#comment-127 I read the graphic novel of this last Fall because it has been recommended to me by a few people and is apparently some great story. I have read some other Alan Moore series and they are a drag to read but usually have a good idea to them and I can usually latch onto that idea at least. That being said, I have heard that the movie is close to the book. So, I have to say that from reading the book and not seeing the movie I am nervous about the length of the movie. The trailers look epic and the chick seems like a hot slut so I'm into that. But if it is truly like the comic, I can see how it would be tedious at points. There are some parts of the novel that I felt I should have skipped because they were boring and I still don't see how they mattered to the story at all. However, I think I might like the movie more than you because I did read the book and know what is going on already. My initial reaction to the book seems like your initial reaction to the movie. I should have read the plot on wikipedia first and then read the book. I don't know how the movie ends but the graphic novel ending SUCKS. I hated it. Character rundown: Silk Spectre I-total slut, glory(hole) whore Silk Spectre II-pretty much a slut, whiny about the whole hero thing, I think being a super hero would be fun as crap for one but she hates it, search me why a 30 year old chick would still be raging against her mommy's control Night Owl I-annoying superman complex old man Night Owl II- fat nerd who lost his will to fight and doesn't get it back until he gets some poon, still a boy scout though Rorschach- AMAZING DUDE, tough as nails, unforgiving Mr Manhattan- God complex guy, can do really cool stuff Comedian- total douche, no question Ozymandias- Has there ever been a more gay/ cliche and boring super hero(villain)? Sorry if that was annoying at all. I read the graphic novel of this last Fall because it has been recommended to me by a few people and is apparently some great story. I have read some other Alan Moore series and they are a drag to read but usually have a good idea to them and I can usually latch onto that idea at least.
That being said, I have heard that the movie is close to the book. So, I have to say that from reading the book and not seeing the movie I am nervous about the length of the movie. The trailers look epic and the chick seems like a hot slut so I’m into that. But if it is truly like the comic, I can see how it would be tedious at points. There are some parts of the novel that I felt I should have skipped because they were boring and I still don’t see how they mattered to the story at all.
However, I think I might like the movie more than you because I did read the book and know what is going on already. My initial reaction to the book seems like your initial reaction to the movie. I should have read the plot on wikipedia first and then read the book.
I don’t know how the movie ends but the graphic novel ending SUCKS. I hated it.

Character rundown:
Silk Spectre I-total slut, glory(hole) whore
Silk Spectre II-pretty much a slut, whiny about the whole hero thing, I think being a super hero would be fun as crap for one but she hates it, search me why a 30 year old chick would still be raging against her mommy’s control
Night Owl I-annoying superman complex old man
Night Owl II- fat nerd who lost his will to fight and doesn’t get it back until he gets some poon, still a boy scout though
Rorschach- AMAZING DUDE, tough as nails, unforgiving
Mr Manhattan- God complex guy, can do really cool stuff
Comedian- total douche, no question
Ozymandias- Has there ever been a more gay/ cliche and boring super hero(villain)?

Sorry if that was annoying at all.

]]> By: Mick http://www.broadaudit.com/archives/62/comment-page-1#comment-126 Mick Sat, 07 Mar 2009 06:24:38 +0000 http://www.broadaudit.com/?p=62#comment-126 I'm a grown man. I like sports. I fuck chicks. BUT I also read comic books and play video games. I also thought this movie (like the book) is too wordy/long for it's own good. I’m a grown man. I like sports. I fuck chicks. BUT I also read comic books and play video games. I also thought this movie (like the book) is too wordy/long for it’s own good.

]]>